The corrosive evil of the Chechen conflict
Date: February 5, 2002
A look at the ferocious misery of Chechnya and the "other" war on terrorism
"People who were my witnesses and informants in Chechnya have died for that reason, and that reason alone, as soon as I left their homes. How am I go on living abroad while others are dying in my place?"
Just before my last trip to Chechnya in mid-September my colleagues at Novaya Gazeta began to receive threats and were told to pass on the message that I shouldn't go to Chechnya any more. If I did, my life would be in danger.
As always, our paper has its own people on the general staff and the ministry of defence - people who broadly share our views. We spoke to people at the ministry but, despite their advice, I did go back to Chechnya, only to find myself blockaded in the capital, Grozny.
The city was sealed off after a series of strange events. Controls were so tight you couldnt even move between different districts within the city, let alone make your way out of Grozny on foot.
On that day, 17 September, a helicopter carrying a commission headed by Major-General Anatoly Pozdnyakov from the general staff in Moscow was shot down directly over the city. He was engaged in work quite unprecedented for a soldier in Chechnya.
Only an hour before the helicopter was shot down, he told me the task of his commission was to gather data on crimes committed by the military, analyse their findings, put them in some order and submit the information for the president's consideration. Nothing of the kind had been done before.
Their helicopter was shot down almost exactly over the city centre. All the members of the commission perished and, since they were already on their way to Khankala airbase to take a plane back to Moscow, so did all the material they had collected. That part of the story was published by Novaya Gazeta.
Before the 19 September issue was sent to the printers, our chief editor Dmitry Muratov was summoned to the ministry of defence (or so I understand) and asked to explain how on earth such allegations could be made. He gave them an answer, after which the pressure really began. There should be no publication, he was told.
Nevertheless, he decided to go ahead, publishing a very truncated version of what I had written. At that point, the same people at the ministry who had claimed our report was false now conceded it was true.
But they began to warn of new threats: they had learned that certain people had run out of patience with my articles. It was, in other words, the same kind of conversation as before my last trip to Chechnya.
Then we heard that a particular officer, a Lieutenant Larin, whom I had described in print as a war criminal, was sending letters to the newspaper and similar notes to the ministry. The deaths and torture of several people lie on his conscience and the evidence against him is incontrovertible.
Soon there were warnings that Id better stay at home. Meanwhile, the internal affairs ministry would track down and arrest this self-appointed military hitman, and deputy minister Vasilyev would himself take charge of the operation. I was supposed to remain at our apartment and go nowhere.
But they made no progress in finding Larin, and I began to realise that this was simply another way of forcing me to stop work. The newspaper decided I should leave the country until the editors were sure I could again live a normal life and resume my work.
The paper was forced to omit from my story the sort of detail that is vital to the credibility of an article like this, which suggested the military themselves had downed the helicopter.
All my subsequent difficulties began with those details. If these details surface, the ministry of defence warned our chief editor, that's the end for you . . . In fact, since I was moving around the city at the time, I can personally testify to what happened, as can others who were there with me.
And these were no ordinary citizens: among them were Chechen policemen and Grozny Energy Company employees who, like me, were trapped inside the city. FSB [former KGB] General Platonov was also there. Currently, he is a deputy to Anatoly Chubais, chief executive of United Energy Systems, a key Kremlin player throughout the 1990s and a hawk on Chechnya.
All these saw and knew exactly what I know. Platonov is not only Chubais's deputy but remains a deputy to FSB director Patrushev (in early 2001, the "anti-terrorist operation" in Chechnya was transferred from the military command of the Combined Forces Group to the FSB and its director Patrushev in Moscow placed in overall charge).
No one else saw and knew as much about what happened as Platonov he couldnt help but see it. Not one person was allowed into the city centre after 9am that morning. And yet a helicopter was downed there. Different branches of the military are split over future policy in Chechnya.
There are good reasons why the recent public statements of defence ministry spokesmen all repeat the same phrases: "We deny the possibility of negotiations"; "Its out of the question";
"We are just doing our job." Indeed they are: their sweep and cleanse operations have become even more brutal. Let us suppose that those representing certain other branches of the military on the ground in Chechnya are pursuing a rather different policy.
That is where you should seek the reason for the deaths of all the commission members. I'm just a small cog in that machine someone who happened to be in the thick of events when no other journalists were around.
Those who want to continue fighting seem to have the upper hand; they represent the more powerful section within the so-called CFG, the Combined Forces Group.
To avoid repetition of the disastrous lack of coordination between ministries of defence and internal affairs and the FSB during the first Chechen conflict in 1994-96, overall command of army, police and other paramilitary and special units (CFG) in the present war was given to the military.
Although the FSB supposedly now exercise overall control of the anti-terrorist operation, the military are too strong for them. On the fateful day the helicopter was downed and the commission perished, not even servicemen and officers were permitted to enter the central, cordoned-off area of Grozny.
Only defence ministry officials were allowed through. Even FSB and ministry of justice people were kept out; that was extraordinary. No one was permitted to enter the area where the helicopter was about to fall: representatives of other military bodies and organisations, even ranking officers, had no right to go there.
I dont think we should expect too much from the defence ministry, nor from President Putin (in the light of the US-led campaign in Afghanistan. Editor). He has received carte blanche to take the measures and employ the forces he considers necessary in Chechnya.
Im thinking of Prime Minister Blair's recent activities and words spoken by Chancellor Schroeder when Putin was visiting Germany. As you know, it was then said that Europe should re-examine its stance on Chechnya.
Their position was already pretty feeble and bore no relation to the real state of affairs in Chechnya and the abuse of human rights there. If, however, they are going to alter their position, then its clear what will happen. In practical terms they'll support Putin.
Whatever he does will be fine by them. I think he's been working steadily and persistently towards that end for some time. And Im sure he'll make good use of it now. Not for the first time in the present war, there's been a battle to see whose nerve is stronger.
Putin held back [over the Wests anti-terrorist operation] for some while: we shant support the Northern Alliance in Afghanistan, he said, but we'll offer them back-up. Then he agreed to supply them with arms and, evidently, advisers. In exchange he received a free hand in Chechnya.
Thats the way things are likely to go, I'm afraid. I cant say when it will happen, but whatever happens there will be a more intensive "liquidation of Chechen partisans". As always in Russia, however, it all depends on the methods to be used. What will the liquidation of Chechen bandits amount to this time?
Will they herd everyone else into concentration camps or hold repeated sweep operations in all the population centres in Chechnya? I cant answer for Chechen President Maskhadov, but will offer a brief analysis of his actions.
In my view, he is doing nothing whatsoever. He has retreated into his shell and is thinking, to the exclusion of all else, about his own immediate future hes forgotten the Chechen nation. Just as the federal authorities in Moscow have abandoned the Chechens, so now have the other side.
The nation has to fend for itself, with no leadership or protection. It survives as best it can. If people need to take revenge for their tortured and murdered relatives, they will. If they need to say nothing, theyll keep their mouths shut.
In such circumstances, which are the equivalent of a civil war, and under continuing pressure from the federal forces, no one today can say whom the Chechen nation would vote for if elections were held. No one now has any idea whom theyd elect and in that respect everyone has committed the same enormous mistake.
Maskhadov has obviously been driven into a corner. But the struggle for independence has become an obsession with him: he will hear of nothing else. I dont really understand what use independence will be to him, when he, Shamil Basayev and his immediate bodyguard are all that's left.
The first duty of a president is to fight for the well-being of his nation. I have my own president and it makes no difference that I personally did not vote for Putin. He remains the most important figure in the Russian state.
And Id like him to enable me, and everyone else, to live a normal life. Im referring to the laws that should govern our existence. I find myself in a situation, however, where no one gives a damn how I survive.
Im cut off from my family. I dont know what will happen in the future to my two children. It is not law that rules Russia today. Theres no person and no organisation to which you can turn and be certain that the laws have any force.
I have no thoughts about my future. And thats the worst of all. I just want everything to change so I can go back and live in Moscow again.
I cant imagine spending any length of time here. Or in any other place, for that matter. I must do all in my power to return to Moscow. But I have no idea when that will be. If people in my country have no protection from this lawless regime, that means I survive here while others are dying.
Over the last year Ive been in that position too often. People who were my witnesses and informants in Chechnya have died for that reason, and that reason alone, as soon as I left their homes.
If it again proves the case, then how can I go on living abroad while others are dying in my place?